Trending Content

“I totally get that!” Queer Clinician Countertransference and Microaggressions

By Gretchen Cooper, LMFT

“I totally get that!” the phrase shoots out without a filter! We lean forward in our chairs, eager to engage with another queer presenting client. Being a queer clinician, or a part of a rainbow family, is a gift. Yet, when we assume our shared umbrella gives us automatic insight into every client’s lived experience, we risk doing harm. In honor of Transgender Awareness Week, I believe it’s important for those of us within/around the community to reflect on how even-well-meaning queer/allied clinicians can fall into countertransference and micro-agressions. When we slow down, and examine our own biases, that is where we leave room for more authentic-affirming care.

In my professional life, I have found it difficult to find material for allied/queer clinicians on working within the community. The resources available primarily focus on folks outside it (potentially assuming if we, ourselves, live within the rainbow we are “all-knowing”) When I taught affirming therapy to graduate students who were specializing in the topic, I encountered many within the community who believed they could do no harm. When I taught about bias, counter transference, and micro-agressions, I got push back. Many decided to share about how much they already knew on the topic, finding the idea they could do any harm, difficult. This is why I kept digging, only to discover there is still so much to learn. Just because we are part of an identity, does not mean we are immune to bias. 

(A small review for those who need it): Microagressions are subtle, everyday occurrences that are intentionally or unintentionally derogatory. Some examples could be: “Who wears the pants? Are you the husband or wife”–imposing heteronormative binaries on a couple. To “You don’t look trans” assuming a person wants to “look” a certain way. Whereas Macroagressions are much louder, overt and systemic. These include hate speech and discriminatory legislation. In much of our reading, the microaggressions mentioned tend to focus on how straight/cisgender clinicians can avoid micro-agressions such as the ones I mentioned. Ones that are cis and heteronormative. However, what so many of the books do not teach are the common tropes, we, as queer clinicians/allies fall into when we identify under the same umbrella. 

When we get a client whom we also identify with (or a family member identifies with), at least with me, I get excited. At the start of my career…..too excited. It is a natural, human response to want to connect with others whom we relate to; however, equally important that we don’t fall into a different kind of micro aggression. Lets go over a few:

  1. The assumption of a shared timeline. We shouldn’t assume the client is current with our own terminology. For example, we are taught to say updated terms like: “Transgender/Trans” vs. “Transvestite/Transexual.” Or “Queer.” If our clients are of a different generation, some of these terms don’t quite “fit” for them. Despite their terms being outdated, it can be helpful to respect the language of our clients, and to check in with them so as not to offend them. I have had older clients hold a great distaste for the word “Queer” as when they grew up it was a slur. Some clients who were older take great pride in the word “Transexual” given its rich history in the movement. For example, a famous publication from the 60’s “Transvestia” magazine had 114 printings, however, was intentionally circulated underground in discreet envelopes to bypass postal surveillance. Language is deeply personal. That does not mean we have to police every word of it, it means we should come from a place of patience and understanding of the world our client grew up in. This doesn’t mean we have to adopt terminology that feels painful or offensive to us; rather, it means stepping back from our own linguistic comfort zones to respect and validate the framework our client relies on. 
  2. Over Identification. Now this is one I know I have fallen into! Having a transgender family member and being queer myself, I have rushed into a casual camaraderie too quickly. This can strip away professional boundaries and make it difficult for the client to express their feelings. It’s alright to “get it” but, we must be careful of how and when we self disclose. I err on the side of stopping myself when I have the urge and asking, “Gretchen, do they really need to know that about you right now? Is this about you feeling connected/lonely? Or will this disclosure truly benefit your client and keep the conversation focused on them?”
  3. Minimization: Another common error we fall into is responding to a client’s pain around discrimination and transphobia. You may lean into, “Well as queer people we all have that…..” This may be an attempt to connect with your client, but we should never normalize discrimination and transphobia. It tends to invalidate their frightening reality and trauma.
  4. Performance Pressure. Finally another common failure of queer/allied therapists is unconsciously holding trans, non-binary, or gender-expansive clients to a standard of resilience and advocacy. This can happen due to our own history surviving discrimination. That we have a duty to “represent” when in actuality, just showing up, a smile at hand, and truly hearing their lived experience IS enough. 
  5. The last micro aggression is assuming “coming out” is necessary or the same for everyone. Coming out, (or “letting in”) is different for each individual. It is rarely a singular, linear process. I have let people in over the years on my sexual orientation and to this day, people still are surprised when they “find out.” I have posted about it, talked casually with friends, and yet I still “shock” people to this day. Most folks “come out” many times in their lives. I’m doing it again, right now! Not all of us have one post, or one giant announcement and then they are done. In my professional career, my orientation is not a mystery. However, in other areas it is! That is also the case for many of our clients. Coming out may have been empowering for you or a family member, but remember it is not always the best journey/or safest for our clients. We need to hold space for that and support them in what is best for them. 

When we inevitably slip into one of these blind spots–the world will not end! Remember, as queer/allied clinicians, that person sitting across from you is generally just as excited as you are to be there! LGBTQ+ clinicians are a rarity in our profession (roughly 12 percent and we don’t have exact numbers). However, with Trans awareness week, it’s important to learn to sit in the discomfort of our own impact. Our true tests aren’t about us being the figurehead of the LGBTQ community, but by showing up.

Ultimately, being an affirming and allied therapist isn’t about having all the right answers or sharing a mirrored identity.  It’s about decentering our own experiences, operating in curiosity, and holding space for the unique realities of our clients. When we embrace each others uniqueness, we return to the true heart of our work.

 


Gretchen Cooper (she/they) is a LMFT, CEU provider, and former graduate faculty member at Antioch University Los Angeles. She is the author of numerous publications and continuing education (CEU) courses focused on LGBTQ+ affirming therapy, sex positivity, and bias awareness. For more information on her psychotherapy practice, publications, and clinical training opportunities, please visit her website. Gretchencoopertherapy.com or follow on instagram @reframewithgretchen